Blog

Moving from CO accounts to Swiss GAAP FER: the case of a Vaud SME

A reconstructed case of a Vaud SME that moved from the Code of Obligations to Swiss GAAP FER: choice of framework, closing errors, cost in CHF and tax effect.

Services fiduciaires
Audit et contrôles internes
Moving from CO accounts to Swiss GAAP FER: the case of a Vaud SME

The starting point: CO accounts were sufficient… until the bank asked

The case described below is reconstructed from similar files and anonymised. No names are cited. The figures are illustrative, except for the legal thresholds, which are those of the law in force.
It concerns a Vaud public limited company in the industrial subcontracting sector, based in the Nord vaudois, with 38 employees. Turnover reached CHF 9.4 million for the 2025 financial year. The accounts were prepared in accordance with the Code of Obligations (CO), articles 957 et seq., with a limited statutory examination entrusted to a licensed auditor.
The thresholds of article 727 CO are well known: an ordinary audit is required where two of the following three criteria are exceeded during two consecutive financial years: a balance sheet total of CHF 20 million, turnover of CHF 40 million, and 250 full-time positions on annual average. The company remained well below them. CO accounts were sufficient for the purposes of the law.
The trigger was banking-related. In October 2025, the institution financing an extension project of CHF 3.2 million required, in order to grant the facility, accounts prepared in accordance with a recognised standard, with a cash flow statement and a detailed notes section. Management's first reflex was to ask the fiduciary firm to add a few tables to the CO accounts. This option was rejected: an ad hoc supplement does not amount to applying a framework.
The CO imposes a minimal framework. Article 958 CO requires annual accounts made up of the balance sheet, the income statement and the notes. It leaves wide latitude for hidden reserves, which is precisely what the bank wanted to neutralise.

Choosing the framework: Swiss GAAP FER, US GAAP or IFRS?

Three frameworks were in competition. The terms must first be distinguished. Swiss GAAP FER are the recommendations on accounting presentation published by the FER foundation (Fondation pour les recommandations relatives à la présentation des comptes). FER designates the foundation; the recommendations themselves are known as the Swiss GAAP FER. US GAAP are the generally accepted accounting principles in the United States, issued by the FASB. IFRS are the international standards of the IASB.
We ruled out US GAAP. Their framework is highly detailed, geared towards listed American companies, and their application requires an expertise that is rare in French-speaking Switzerland. The estimated cost of compliance exceeded CHF 60'000 for a company of this size. No American subsidiary or shareholder justified it.
We ruled out IFRS for reasons of proportion. IFRS comprise several dozen standards, with fair value measurement requirements and disclosures that make the notes heavier. The estimate stood between CHF 45'000 and CHF 55'000 for the first year, with a closing timetable lengthened by three to four weeks. The bank did not require this level.
Swiss GAAP FER offered the best balance between readability and burden. They are designed for Swiss SMEs, recognised by banks and accepted by most lenders. The conceptual framework requires a true and fair presentation of the financial position, which is what the bank was seeking. The choice was settled in November 2025, with an initial budget of CHF 18'000 and a four-month timetable.
Estimated cost of compliance
US GAAPMore than CHF 60'000
IFRSCHF 45'000 to CHF 55'000 in the first year
Swiss GAAP FERInitial budget of CHF 18'000
Closing timetable
US GAAPNot quantified in the case
IFRSLengthened by 3 to 4 weeks
Swiss GAAP FERImplementation timetable of 4 months
Complexity / expertise required
US GAAPHighly detailed framework, geared towards listed American companies; rare expertise in French-speaking Switzerland
IFRSSeveral dozen standards; fair value measurement; heavier notes
Swiss GAAP FERDesigned for Swiss SMEs; 6 core FER; notes of about a dozen pages
Fit with the need
US GAAPNo American subsidiary or shareholder to justify it
IFRSLevel of requirement higher than that requested by the bank
Swiss GAAP FERRecognised by banks; true and fair presentation of the financial position; adopted in November 2025
Swiss GAAP FER offer the best balance of readability and burden: US GAAP and IFRS cost 3 times as much for a level that the bank did not require

Key takeaway

For a Vaud SME of 38 employees with no American link, Swiss GAAP FER meet the bank's requirement for a budget of CHF 18'000, compared with more than CHF 45'000 for IFRS and more than CHF 60'000 for US GAAP.
Source: FER Foundation (Swiss GAAP FER); arts. 727 and 958 CO — fedlex.admin.ch; anonymised case, illustrative figures

Choosing the FER standards: the 6 core FER or the 21 full FER?

Swiss GAAP FER comprise six core standards, numbered FER 1 to 6, and complementary standards. The six core standards are: FER 1 (principles), FER 2 (valuation), FER 3 (presentation and structure), FER 4 (cash flow statement), FER 5 (off-balance-sheet commitments) and FER 6 (notes). They form the foundation applicable to small organisations.
The criteria for application are set by the FER foundation. An organisation may limit its scope to the six core standards if it does not exceed two of the following three thresholds over two financial years: a balance sheet total of CHF 10 million, turnover of CHF 20 million, and 50 full-time positions on annual average. Our company was below these thresholds. It was therefore able to adopt the six core FER.
As the company is not a non-profit organisation, the Swiss GAAP FER 21 standard did not apply. This standard is specific to charitable social organisations, foundations and charitable associations. A foundation client of the firm would apply Swiss GAAP FER 21 in addition to the core standards, which notably adds the performance report and the statement of changes in capital.
This choice has a direct effect on cost. The scope of the six core standards reduced the notes to about a dozen pages, compared with more than twenty for the full scope. The budget of CHF 18'000 was thus largely maintained. The final decision on scope remains to be validated with the audit body and the lender.

Errors in the first closing

The first closing produced four errors. Each is presented in the sequence decision, error, cost, correction.
First error, the opening balance sheet. Decision: carry over the CO balance sheet at 1 January 2026 without prior restatement. Error: inventories, written down by 40% out of prudence under commercial law, did not correspond to the FER 2 valuation basis. Cost: 6 additional working days. Correction: revaluation of inventories at net realisable value, which increased inventory by CHF 310'000.
Second error, provisions. Decision: keep the flat-rate provisions of the CO. Error: FER 23 and FER 1 require a past event and a probable outflow of resources. A general provision of CHF 120'000 for miscellaneous risks could not be justified. Cost: 3 days. Correction: release of CHF 120'000 and retention of only the documented provisions, notably CHF 45'000 for warranty.
Third error, fixed assets. Decision: keep the declining-balance tax depreciation. Error: FER 3 and FER 18 require depreciation according to useful life. Cost: 5 days and a difference of CHF 180'000 on the net value of the machinery. Correction: fixed asset schedule recalculated on useful lives of 8 to 12 years.
Fourth error, the cash flow statement and the interim balance sheet. Decision: build the cash flow statement at the end of the closing. Error: without an interim balance sheet at 30 June, the half-yearly comparatives requested by the bank were missing. Cost: 4 days under urgency. Correction: interim balance sheet reconstructed, then a half-yearly timetable built into the procedure.

Results: restated equity, actual cost in CHF, closing timetable

The restatements changed equity in contrasting ways. The increase in inventories (plus CHF 310'000) and the release of the general provision (plus CHF 120'000) increased equity. The revision of depreciation (minus CHF 180'000) and the recognition of deferred taxes on these differences (minus CHF 74'000) reduced it. Net: plus CHF 176'000, bringing equity from CHF 2.41 million under CO accounts to CHF 2.59 million under Swiss GAAP FER.
One restatement therefore reduced equity, and this must be stated as such: depreciation based on useful life lowered the value of the machinery. The equity ratio rose from 31% to 33% of the balance sheet total, a result that the bank accepted without additional conditions.
The actual cost came to CHF 26'500, against a budget of CHF 18'000. The difference stems from the 18 working days linked to the four errors above. The closing timetable went from 5 to 8 weeks in the first year. We estimate it will come down to 6 weeks for the following financial year.
Effect on Vaud cantonal tax: no change in basis. The tax base remains the result of the accounts prepared in accordance with the CO, with the corrections provided for by the cantonal direct tax law. Swiss GAAP FER substitute nothing for it. The differences between the two sets of accounts were documented in a reconciliation table, useful in the event of an assessment at the tax authority's discretion or an audit by the cantonal tax administration. No tax saving is expected from this change.
The reference sources are the FER foundation (fer.ch), the CO on fedlex.admin.ch and the documentation of audit firms on Swiss GAAP FER. Final decisions rest with the audit body and the company's adviser.

What is transferable

Five points emerge from this case for a Vaud SME facing an accounting standard requirement.
1. Draw up the starting checklist before any restatement: signed CO balance sheet, list of inventories, provisions and fixed assets, financing agreement with the accounting clause. Allow half a day.
2. Quantify the choice of framework in three columns (Swiss GAAP FER, IFRS, US GAAP) with cost and timetable, and document it in writing. For a company with no foreign shareholder, Swiss GAAP FER are generally the proportionate framework.
3. Plan the standard timetable: restated opening balance sheet in month 1, interim balance sheet at 30 June in month 2, annual closing in month 3, reconciliation table to the tax base in month 4. Allow a 20% margin on the budget in the first year.
4. Approach the audit body before the first closing, not after. An exchange on the opening balance sheet and on the scope of the standards (6 core FER or full FER) avoids late corrections.
5. Maintain two consistent sets of accounts: the CO for Vaud taxation and entry in the commercial register, Swiss GAAP FER for the lender. An annual reconciliation table guarantees traceability.
To explore the comparison of frameworks further, see Swiss GAAP vs IFRS: which standard suits your company?, as well as GAAP accounting: definition and operation in Switzerland.
"This article provides general information on GAAP accounting standards for informational purposes only; it does not constitute personalised legal, tax or accounting advice. For any specific situation, consult a qualified professional before making a decision."

FAQ

FER designates the foundation that publishes the standards. Swiss GAAP FER designates the recommendations on accounting presentation themselves. The two terms are often used interchangeably, but they do not refer to the same thing.

Assess the move to Swiss GAAP FER

Has a lender required accounts in accordance with a recognised standard? We analyse your situation, quantify the scope and plan the first closing with your audit body.

Author image

Élodie Rochat

[email protected]

Moving from CO accounts to Swiss GAAP FER: the case of a Vaud SME